Tuesday, June 05, 2007

Securing Kerala

In recent weeks, Kerala Chief Minister Achuthanthan has caught the state by surprise by sending earthmovers and bulldozers to Munnar to remove illegal encroachments, including properties owned by politicians of all hues. In the process, his actions have won the hearts of some of his staunchest critics among the public. Around the same time that Achuthanthan decided to move against what has come to be known as the "land mafia", he also announced plans to reverse paddy reclamation projects throughout the state. As rice has fallen out of favour with Kerala farmers, paddy fields have given way to other crops and commercial enterprises. Expressing concern for the state's food security, Achuthanthan has proposed actions against real estate firms who buy paddy fields and convert them for alternative purposes. Unfortunately, these latest developments show that he, among other politicians, have a poor understanding of Kerala's needs.

Illegal encroachments are consequences of an economy with increasing disposable income but comparatively few investment opportunties. And whether we're talking about non-resident Keralites sending home more and more remittances every year or real estate firms reacting to economic opportunities in Kerala, the reality is that Kerala has to proactively react to the demands of an increasingly wealthy population. And this is where it is falling behind today.

First, let us give Achuthanthan credit where he is due. Forest lands are government property for the very reason that free markets are imperfect. Forest lands have enormous positive externalities, because they are an important link in the biological cycle. Some of the Munnar forests contain the most pristine vegetation in Kerala. They are habitats to wild animals that form an important part of the food chain. They potentially harbor plants whose medicinal value are inadequately documented. Forests also act as carbon dioxide reservoirs, playing increasingly significant roles as the world searches for solutions to air pollution. They hold more benefits to society than can be accounted for, and thus do not compensate private holders as they should. In private hands, they would not be conserved as they mean more to society as a whole than to private individuals. Their viability are best left to a public authority appointed by society. However, forest departments and land revenue departments can be lax when there are not enough incentives in place to maintain healthy forests. Let us not forget that it is the political class which is responsible for many instances of illegal encroachments, so change should begin at the top. So, let us hope that our Chief Minister also turns his attention to the systemic flaws that lead to the misuse of public lands.

In contrast, the Chief Minister's plans for paddy fields, have very little to do with the reality of a growing Kerala and owes more to his fixation on food security. This unhealthy obssession is partly rooted in Kerala’s history. In particular, the political class in Kerala still suffers a hangover from the food crisis in 1964, when the existing Communist government was booted out and the state was placed under Central rule. The four states of Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu and Kerala were then consolidated into a single food trading zone. Instead of letting food prices prevail at market rates and intervening for the most marginalized consumers, the Central government placed price ceilings on the stocks it purchased in the name of rationing. So while wealthier consumers in Kerala were able to pay the rates that Andhra suppliers demanded, ration ships ran out of stock as the State government refused to budge on prices. Kerala tided over the crisis temporarily with imports from countries including the U.S. and Pakistan and over time developed a more efficient distribution system. So, Achuthanthan's concern for rice’s dwindling prospects in Kerala almost seem justified. Almost.

It is difficult to justify a labor-intensive crop like rice in a state that has near 100% literacy and is better off by putting its human resources in more productive industries. Kerala's achievements in educating its people are precisely why paddy fields are dwindling from their peak in the 1970s. The mass spread of education, pre- and post-Independence, opened up alternative sources of employment for millions of Keralites within the short span of two or three generations. Workers from communities that historically depended on agriculture suddenly found more lucrative opportunities in retail, education, civil service, construction, tourism etc. It's the classic textbook case of economic diversification within an increasingly skilled workforce. Meanwhile, rice's viability as a crop has diminished significantly with rising labor costs.

But despite the diminishing contribution of rice to the local economy, Achuthanthan believes that Kerala should spend valuable taxpayers' money on increasing the cultivation of rice in the name of food security. If we define food security as a state where people are capable of feeding themselves, Kerala is not facing a food crisis by any measure. If anything, most Keralites are employed in those jobs where they are most productive and can earn enough to feed themselves. The only need for an intervention would be for those marginalized consumers, or "non-consumers", for whom the price of rice puts it effectively out of their reach. It is conceivable that these non-consumers have grown in number in recent times as food prices have risen. Yet, is forcing farmers and industrialists to switch to paddy the most effective way to feed these marginalized people?

If Achuthananthan's true goal is food security, he has two options: 1) procure food at market rates and subsidize them for the marginalized consumers or 2) grow food locally and provide it to the needy. The latter is far more disruptive because it ignores the merits of a competitive market and creates a deadweight loss to the state. With option 1, he can obtain rice at the cheapest rates possible from other sources. With option 2, he forces farmers to grow rice in the place of more valuable and less-labor intensive crops and thus reduces their incomes. But, even if he were to subsidize those farmers and prevent any loss of income to them, Kerala would be paying for a relatively expensive crop, creating an even greater bill for taxpayers. So, one has to assume that Achuthanthan believes that there is some intangible benefit the balances the cost of encouraging paddy growth. Therein lies the unspoken, irrational fears that "food security" have come to represent.

Food security as an argument belies many of the irrational fears that politicians hold about free trade and farming constituencies. Achuthanthan’s paddy project is inherently about his staunch belief that Kerala should produce its own food and his insecurity with free markets. According to our leaders, we should support rice farmers even if we have to pay more for their rice and create fields when there is no need for more. This irrational argument ignores the very basic fact that Kerala consumers are not restricted to Kerala’s products and should be able to choose from the larger Indian and world markets. The hype around "food security" also ignores Kerala’s ability to focus on more productive sectors of the economy so that it can create more wealth and its people can eat more than a daily plate of gruel. In a nutshell, paddy reclamation is a wasteful exercise for a state with better things to do.

Yet, there is no dearth for meaningful reforms if Achuthanthan seriously wishes to pursue greater food security for Kerala. For example, he can begin by reforming one of the most antiquated laws in Kerala agriculture, the Kerala Land Utilisation Order of 1967. The 1967 legislation was passed with the express intention to lock up agricultural land in Kerala, including paddy fields, within agriculture. Passed in the hindsight of the ’64 crisis, the Order introduced tremendous restrictions in converting fallow paddy fields to commercial usage. However, as rice prices have fallen and labor costs risen since the Act was passed, huge swathes of paddy fields have been converted surreptiously or left barren in the absence of government permission. In the process, environmental activists have lost considerably in their fight to reforest paddy fields and restore pre-agriculture ecosystems as needed. Owners of smaller landholdings have been unable to take advantage of much needed capital investment and consolidation. And illegal encroachments have proliferated as scrupulous dealers have turned their eyes to less well protected public lands in the absence of commercially zoned real estate. The ’67 Order is increasingly endangering the delicate relationship between public and private lands. Ironically, it has even failed to play any substantial role in increasing food security. Because in a market like India, where people are free to trade across state borders, food security has little to do with local crops and more to do with economic security.

Kerala's food crisis in 1964 was only superficially the result of inadequate agricultural output. The 1964 crisis was in part driven by Kerala’s impoverishment and lack of economic diversification. A community’s dependence on agriculture leaves it exposed to a considerable amount of risk, for e.g. the risk that a bad drought will bring a poor harvest. Kerala's lack of value-added products and a largely unskilled workforce in the 1970s left a large section of society exposed to the highly variable price of a commoditized product. So in the past, local food insecurity has always fed economic insecurity and vice versa – i.e. a fall in food production often led to a loss in income for a large portion of Keralites, thus reducing the ability to buy food and so on. Today, the situation is very different with Kerala having diversified significantly into the services sector and a large proportion of skilled and unskilled workforce having migrated overseas. The debilitating link between food production and economic insecurity has weakened considerably. Most Keralites no longer rely on the comparatively cheaper and inferior rice from public distribution system as they are generally wealthier than their predecessors and can afford to buy better quality rice at prevailing rates. Ultimately, Achuthanthan's paddy reclamation initiative is not only a solution to a non-existant problem; it also does little to improve Kerala's economic security, which as history shown, is the best driver of food insecurity.

Labels: , , , , , ,


Blogger kk said...

This is a great article.
News from "Gods Own Country" - Kerala

6/10/2007 1:46 AM  
Blogger Here you will find said...

Great post. Cheers!

7/09/2007 5:12 PM  
Anonymous Tarun Gupta said...

I read your blog and thought I could tell you about something else which would be useful for seeing maps and directions in India.

I am writing to tell you about MapmyIndia.com, a free interactive maps and directions portal for all India.

We have recently launched our next generation v2008, whose main focus is to provide meaningful and useful directions from anywhere to anywhere in India. Next time you need to go somewhere unfamiliar, we want you to know you have a reliable and easy option to get directions – MapmyIndia.com!

As a company and individual enthusiasts, we dream only of solving the problem of reliable directions and navigation for India. For your blog specifically, you can map enable it by using our youtube-style embeddable maps, and links to specific searches (of maps, directions, local and eLocation) on MapmyIndia.

Do give us feedback, suggestions, or get involved yourself by mailing me back at tarun@mapmyindia.com or marketing@mapmyindia.com.

And if you find the different services useful, we would be grateful to you for writing and telling your readers about us.

Warm Regards,
Tarun Gupta
The MapmyIndia Team
For directions in India, just search print and go with MapmyIndia.com

9/14/2007 3:59 AM  
Anonymous sunilmenonin@gmail.com said...

Hi Abhishek,are you a scribe?,why waste energy and be uptight.Tangential,digressive,a Joseph Stiglitz in the making.

10/08/2007 5:19 AM  
Blogger Aditya said...

Thanks for sharing. Keep writing Your blog is nice & great blog. I think you should add your blog at www.blogadda.com and let more people discover your blog. It's a great place for Indian bloggers to be in and I am sure it would do wonders for your blog.

10/19/2007 2:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello I just entered before I have to leave to the airport, it's been very nice to meet you, if you want here is the site I told you about where I type some stuff and make good money (I work from home): here it is

10/26/2007 12:52 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi, this is not so related to your page, but it is the site you asked me 1 month ago about the abs diet. I tried it, worked well. Well here is the site

10/28/2007 3:49 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Abhishek,
your article is very thoughtful and insightful. please write more articles like this.
joshi, u.k.

12/09/2007 4:02 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice to see a wonderful blog. Please review my blog and give a comment http://varthakeralam.blogspot.com

thanks for your visit.

4/20/2008 1:27 PM  
Blogger Sakthi said...

The seed of communism has spread across kerala like weed. No development is possible as long as communists and their puppies(DYFI and SFI) are there. A daily wage earner and govt office employees all want a dose of Stalin and Lenin at the end of the day(along with a bottle of toddy. prepared by comrades after mixing with yesterday's kunji water). They get goosebumps when they talk about china(the paradise for them). These days top comrades are busy DISTURBING THE TRADITIONS OF THE TEMPLE, AND MAKING MONEY WITH FRAUD SANTHOSHMADHAVAN
So but far away in Bengal, Buddha is laughing and crying hysterically what his comrades have been doin since last 30 years. Even after 30 years, there are hand-pulled rikshaws running in Kolkata.
I am sure once the oil get dried up in gulf, we are also going to do the same. you can see the handpulled rikshaw everywhere. They will run from Kochi to Thiruvandapuram also.

6/02/2008 1:01 PM  
Blogger Club.mocazo said...

Its really nice blog can u check my blog once for more Malayalam stuff like Latest aakashagopuram movie mohanlal wallpapers, ringtones, posters, more Mohanlal fans online meet Malayalam friends Log on ::Aakashagopuram Malayalam Mohanlal Movie

9/08/2008 12:33 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ലോകമെമ്പാടുമുള്ള 1000കണക്കിന്‌ മലയാളീകളെ കണ്ടെടുക്കുക

നിങ്ങള്‍ ആഗ്രഹിക്കുന്നുവെങ്കില്‍ നമുക്ക് ഒന്നായി ചേര്‍ന്ന് ഒറ്റ സമൂഹമായി ഒരു കുടക്കീഴില്‍ അണിചേര്‍ന്നിടാം. നിങ്ങളുടെ ചിന്തകളും വികാരങ്ങളും പരസ്പരം പങ്കു വയ്ക്കാന്‍ ആഗ്രഹിക്കുന്നുവോ ? ദയവായി ഇവിടെ ക്ലിക് ചെയ്യുക http://www.keralitejunction.com

ഇതിന്‌ ഒപ്പമായി മലയാളീകളുടെ കൂട്ടായ്മയും ഇവിടെ വീക്ഷിക്കാം http://www.keralitejunction.com

11/03/2008 11:03 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


11/18/2009 12:59 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

援交友留言,視訊聊天室,成人貼圖站,情色視訊,情色論壇,美女圖片,080視訊聊天室,正妹牆qk176,18sxe成人影城,080視訊聊天室,免費交友,情色a片,台灣成人網,情色a片,聊天交友,台灣情色,情人貼圖,上班族聊天室f1,成人網,正妹交友,成人視訊,彰化人聊天室,台灣情色網,免費聊天,美女交友,丁字褲美女寫真,情色,免費視訊聊天室,777成人區,哈啦聊天室,0401視訊美女,免費色情影片,成人視訊,免費視訊,正妹牆自拍, ut聊天室,免費視訊,免費視訊g,八國聯軍成人,聊天室ut,

12/07/2009 1:09 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


12/13/2009 4:24 PM  
Anonymous martin mark said...

fantastic post!!

hr diploma | phd degree human resource management | associate degree international business

12/22/2009 6:09 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


1/12/2010 11:27 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Birth is much but breeding is more. 加油! ....................................................

1/24/2010 12:25 PM  
Blogger 跌倒 said...

Everyone fastens where there is gain. ....................................................

2/02/2010 3:05 PM  
Blogger 英文發音真難 said...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。 ..................................................

2/27/2010 10:42 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...


Over the past 30 years, Mansour Engineering have completed thousands of projects of varying degrees of complexity in Ontario, Alberta, Saskatchewan, British Columbia, Nova Scotia, Quebec, the Yukon and Northwest territories

[url=http://www.mansour.ca] click here to go to Mansour Engineering[/url]


3/07/2010 5:05 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Glad to greet you, ladies and gentlemen!

Let me introduce myself,
friends call me Peter.
Generally I’m a venturesome gambler. all my life I’m carried away by online-casino and poker.
Not long time ago I started my own blog, where I describe my virtual adventures.
Probably, it will be interesting for you to find out how to win not loose.
Please visit my web page . http://allbestcasino.com I’ll be interested on your opinion..

3/11/2010 3:47 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Free ebay finally

http://www.BuySellDirect.net is the Future of FREE E-commerce where you can sell your products and make real money at home.

http://www.BuySellDirect.net 100% free service is all you need to make real money on the internet.

4/27/2010 6:08 PM  
Anonymous Evergreen songs said...

great work and vision

5/25/2010 6:27 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

കൊള്ളാം. നന്നായിട്ടുണ്ട്.
ഇതുപോലുള്ള പോസ്റ്റുകള്‍ ഇനിയും പ്രതീക്ഷിക്കുന്നു.

7/10/2010 12:58 AM  
Blogger Pushpendra singh said...

India is know as golden bird because of its beauty. There are several beautiful place like hill station,beach,temple,fort and so many things.KERLA is one of them IT is known for natural beauty.
If u want to go kerala in India then must visit on
kerala tour
kerala tours
Kerala Tour Packages
kerala holiday packages
kerala tour operator
kerala tour itinerary
kerala backwaters tour
kerala honeymoon packages
Kerala Tour Planner

6/28/2011 12:15 AM  
Anonymous kerala real estate said...

As a company and individual enthusiasts, we dream only of solving the problem of reliable directions and navigation for India.

9/27/2011 4:11 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Rajasthan is the most colorful region in India exhibiting splendor and royalty in every walk of life. It is truly said "a land of valiance and chivalry ", which is endowed with invincible forts, magnificent palaces, waves of sand dunes and serene lakes. No other region in the country assembles as many paradoxes of India as does the desert land of Rajasthan.
Rajasthan holiday packages

9/27/2011 11:53 PM  
Anonymous european mountains said...

There is something really missing in the blog .. Don't know what ..

12/08/2011 8:06 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ativan 2mg ativan 64 - ativan oral uses

3/16/2013 12:29 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

People who have properly monitored to pay off their monthly bills and set away a great deal of funds to their cost savings accounts all concur - should your objective is always to acquire control of your own personal budget, environment a budget, and adhering to that budget, is going to be necessary to your prosperity. [url=http://www.ss12w12ws.info]Vicinffu7ity[/url]

3/29/2013 3:15 PM  
Blogger HcoRealEstate said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

4/17/2013 12:13 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hello thеrе and thank you for your infoгmation – I've definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise a few technical issues using this web site, since I experienced to reload the site many times previous to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK? Not that I'm complaining, but sluggish loading instances times wіll very fгеquently affect
your placеment іn gоogle
and could damаge yοur high-quality score іf advertіsing
anԁ mаrκeting with Adwords. Well I'm adding this RSS to my email and can look out for much more of your respective interesting content. Ensure that you update this again soon.

Here is my webpage High Stakes Bonus

5/30/2013 9:16 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I appreciate the ideas and I would like to read more good stuff keep it up! This is very nice article and have great information. I have also avail information about the best new project..ATS Pristine

7/26/2013 4:48 AM  
Anonymous Indian Engineers said...

If you are a Science, Engineering or Technology professional of Indian origin, please join Indian Engineers ( http://www.indianengineers.com) - a discussion and networking forum for engineers of Indian origin.
There is a wealth of information out there among our Engineers, Technologists and Accademics. We believe this can be used for the benefit of young STEM (science, technology, engineering and maths) students and professionals alike.

11/12/2014 9:27 AM  
Blogger Qadit Qadit said...

Thank you for your wonderful words............We offer superior network security solutions to assist service suppliers, enterprises and the public sector produce price accelerate success.

Network security solutions

4/11/2015 3:13 AM  
Blogger Qadit System said...

Thank u Very much For this Useful Information… We offer superior network security solutions in Kerala to assist service suppliers, enterprises and the public sector produce price accelerate success.
Network security solutions in Kerala

7/02/2015 10:49 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home